Deep Dive: Semantic Frames & Conceptual Metaphors
Underlying narratives are deep linguistic structures that help us make sense of the world – often operating at an unconscious level. We focus on two important tools for analyzing how narratives work: Semantic Frames and Conceptual Metaphors.
Semantic Frames
Semantic Frames are cognitive structures that shape how we understand the world. They help us process and categorize information (our thoughts and experiences) by linking words to shared cultural understandings.
In the field of Linguistics, the idea of semantic frames came from linguist Charles Fillmore in the 1900’s, who described a frame as a conceptual scenario involving participants, roles, and relationships. For example, when we hear “She gave me a gift,” we automatically understand it in terms of a Giving frame. This frame includes a giver, a recipient, and an object – even if some of these elements are not explicitly stated. Frames help us infer meaning from partial information and guide how we interpret events.
Frames are not neutral. They are culturally shaped and often carry ideological assumptions. For instance, describing someone as “homeless” may activate a victim or charity frame, whereas calling them “unhoused” can activate a structural or rights-based frame. These differences influence what we perceive as the problem, who we see as responsible, and what kind of solution seems appropriate.
Common Features of a Semantic Frame
Feature | Description | Example (Giving Frame) |
---|---|---|
Frame | Conceptual scenario | Giving |
Roles | Key participants in the scenario | Giver, recipient, object |
Relations | Expected interactions between roles | Transfer of possession |
Inferences | What we assume even if unstated | There is an intention to give |
Conceptual Metaphors
Conceptual Metaphors are cognitive mappings that help us make sense of intangible, abstract ideas by linking them to familiar, physical experiences (e.g. motion “moving forward”, sight “seeing clearly”, touch, temperature, and other sensory cues that ground meaning in the body). They are deep, archetypal mental models, not just a figure of speech.
Conceptual Metaphor Theory (developed by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson) shows that much of our everyday language and thought is metaphorical. For example, the metaphor “Time is money” appears in phrases like “spend time,” “waste time,” or “invest your time wisely.” The metaphor “Life is a journey” shows up in “stay on track” or “at a crossroads.”
Connection between Conceptual Metaphors and Semantic Frames: Conceptual metaphors build on the structure of Semantic Frames: they take the structural knowledge from a concrete domain (known as “source domain”), for example money or travel. And map it onto an abstract domain (known as “target domain”), like time, or love. The semantic frame provides the logic, roles and relations (e.g. through the frame Money, we automatically think of spending, investing etc).
Conceptual metaphors often activate or align with semantic frames. For example, saying “We need to jumpstart the economy,” uses the metaphor “The economy is a machine,” which fits into a broader mechanistic economic frame that assumes technical control and repair.
Examples of Conceptual Metaphors
Conceptual Metaphor | Source Domain(embodied/concrete) | Target Domain(abstract) | Example Phrases |
---|---|---|---|
Time is money | Finance | Time | “Spend time,” “waste time” |
Life is a journey | Travel | Life | “Stay on track,” “hit a crossroads” |
Argument is war | Combat | Debate | “He attacked my point” |
Ideas are food | Ingestion | Understanding | “Digest that idea,” “half-baked” |
Time is Money → Finance → Time → “Spend time” → “Waste time”
Life is a Journey → Travel → Life → “Stay on track” → “At a crossroads”
Argument is War → Combat → Debate → “He attacked my point” → “Defend your position”
Ideas are Food → Ingestion → Understanding → “Digest that idea” → “Half-baked”
Primary Metaphors
Many Conceptual Metaphors are rooted primary metaphors (basic associations learned through bodily experience). These emerge from repeated correlations in daily life: e.g. warmth with affection or verticality with quantity. These metaphors are largely unconscious, but they form the building blocks of more complex metaphor systems.
Examples of Primary Metaphors
Primary Metaphor | The embodied or concrete | The abstract concept | Example Phrase |
---|---|---|---|
Affection is warmth | Being held as a child | Emotional connection | “She gave me a warm smile” |
More is up | Water level rises when more is added | Quantity | “Prices went up” |
Important is heavy | Heavier objects require more effort | Significance | “That’s a weighty issue” |
Understanding is seeing | Visual clarity | Comprehension | “I see what you mean” |
Together, Semantic Frames and Conceptual Metaphors offer a lens for understanding how language encodes worldview. Frames structure scenarios (role & relations); metaphors map meaning and ground abstract thought in the body. By becoming aware of these linguistic patterns, we can begin to see how meaning is shaped and how it might be reshaped to support cultural transformation.
Footnotes
- This has been explore extensive by George Lakoff – the cognitive scientist often cited as the father of framing: https://george-lakoff.com/2024/04/10/the-power-of-unconscious-thought/
- https://george-lakoff.com/2014/02/18/charles-fillmore-discoverer-of-frame-semantics-dies-in-sf-at-84-he-figured-out-how-framing-works/
- Explore more examples: Robinson, R., Colour of Change USA, on telling the right story on race during COVID-19.
- Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (2008). Metaphors we live by. University of Chicago press
- The concept was developed by Joseph Grady in the 1990s Grady, J. E. (1997). Foundations of meaning: Primary metaphors and primary scenes. University of California, Berkeley.